Salt Lake doesn’t do boring ice cream. Around here, you’ll find scoop shops serving flavors like lavender honey, coconut sticky rice, and mangoneada.
Some are dairy-free. Some are nostalgic. All of them have serious personality.
If you’re on the hunt for a sweet treat that’s anything but ordinary, these six local ice cream spots are absolutely worth checking out, even if there’s a bit of a line.
Blacksmith Ice Cream Co.
Blacksmith Ice Cream Co. is tiny, charming, and usually packed—and for good reason. They churn every batch by hand, which makes the texture super smooth and rich.
The Honeybud (lavender with honey and bits of honeycomb) is unreal. The caramel cashew is another solid favorite. Plus, their oat- and coconut-based dairy-free options are actually amazing, not just an afterthought.
Leatherby’s Family Creamery
This is the kind of spot where you go big. Giant sundaes, massive scoops, and all the toppings you can think of.
Leatherby’s has been around for decades and still makes their ice cream the old-fashioned way. The Biscoff cookie butter flavor is everything. It’s always full of families, so it gets loud and lively fast—so if you want a quieter visit, get it to go.
Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream
Tucked away in Sandy, this place is a hidden gem with a huge flavor list. They rotate 48 flavors every month, so there’s always something new to try.
If you’re into banana ice cream, get the Monkey Business since it’s hard to find a good one like this. The cones are dipped in chocolate and peanuts, which adds a nice crunch. It’s small but crazy popular, so prepare for a line.
Dolcetti Gelato
Want real Italian gelato in Salt Lake? This is it. The flavors are super creamy and dense, so you get more flavor in every bite.
Pistachio and tiramisu are top-tier, but don’t sleep on the seasonal stuff like peach sorbetto or coconut sticky rice. Dolcetti Gelato also serves espresso and pastries if you want to chill for a bit. The vibe inside is funky and cool with lots of vintage décor and cozy corners.
Altojitos
This spot is fun, friendly, and packed with flavor. It’s part ice cream shop, part Mexican snack bar, and all delicious. If you’re into sweet-spicy combos, get the mangoneada or anything with chamoy and Tajín.
The “Oday” (a snow cone and ice cream mix) is super refreshing, and they even have mini pancakes and savory snacks like tostiesquite. Overall, it’s great for a casual hangout or a treat after a long day.
Snelgrove Ice Cream
Snelgrove is all about classic vibes and rich, nostalgic flavors. They’ve been around for nearly a century, and their slow-churned style really shows in the texture.
The Raspberry Oreo is worth the trip alone. It’s creamy, fruity, and packed with cookies. They offer samples, which helps because some flavors are unexpected.
Plan Your Own Ice Cream Adventure
There’s no shortage of great ice cream in Salt Lake, but these six spots really stand out. Each one brings something different to the table, from nostalgic scoops to bold, unexpected flavors.
If you haven’t tried them yet, now’s the time to map out your own little ice cream tour. Bring a friend, try something weird, and don’t skip the waffle cone. You’ll probably find a new favorite and maybe even a new craving.
Leave a Reply